He gives her his best innocent smile--which might not actually come across as innocent at all but he's really not too sure, he doesn't practice this one often--and shrugs, picking up a candy cane of his own and dangling the curved end over his finger as he arches an eyebrow.

"Guess you'll never know until you try. But then again, if you don't try, you'll never know the taste of candy that exists year-round, just not in holiday-specific caned form so... I don't know, potential for death or promise of sugary goodness? Only you can decide what's worth the risk."